by Joe Loizzo

The following tribute, written by Joe Loizzo, was shared at a gathering of family and friends at Menla Mountain Retreat on August 3rd, 2026, to honor Bob’s 49th day through the bardo (which coincided with his actual birthday—which would have been his 85th), and his day of “re-birth.” It was an afternoon of Tibetan prayers and heartfelt speeches from close family members, students, colleagues, and friends whose lives were forever changed by Tenzin Bob.

The first time I met Bob was at Amherst in 1973. It was the fall of my freshman year, my first religion class. Fortuitously, it was also Bob’s first class as a newly minted junior faculty member. At the blackboard end of the long conference table sat John Pemberton, a duck-hunting full professor of Middle Eastern and African Religion straight out of central casting, with his wire-rimmed glasses, proverbial tweed jacket and proper bow tie. On the window end sat Bob, with his dirty-blonde mane, one glass eye, crumpled corduroy sport coat and loose, wildflower tie. The class was supposed to be team-taught, but I can’t for the life of me recall a word Pemberton said. But the Buddhaverse that Bob transported us to—the awe-inspiring interior world of Marpa and Milarepa, Yamantaka and Vajrayogini—over the semester, and the next fifty years, inexorably became the ground I walk on and the air I breathe.

It was clear on day one that Bob was no ordinary professor, nor an ordinary man of his, or any, generation. But who was he? Where did he come from? A day at a time, as he invited me into his visionary life and world, and as he and Nena welcomed me into their home and family, those questions, along with the existential ones I brought with me to college, dissolved.

Like Buddha, Bob was a prince of the most powerful empire of his time, whose privileged life was shattered in a single stroke of suffering. Bob lost his eye in an accident at the age of twenty. Having just read Armenian mystic George Gurdjieff’s Meetings with Remarkable Men, he boldly set aside the life he’d made to journey  on foot across the Middle East in search of remarkable men who could help him create a new one of greater meaning and purpose. His odyssey led him to the Tibetan community in exile in India, and from there to the figures who would become lifelong mentors: the Mongolian teacher Geshe Wangyal, H.H. the Dalai Lama, Yongzin Ling Rimpoche, Tsanshab Serkhong Rimpoche and Tara Tulku Rimpoche.

His Holiness instantly saw in the twenty-one-year-old seeker a fierce deity from the West, who had given his left eye to open his wisdom eye. After his years as a Tantric monk at Gyuto Monastery in North India, living into the visionary world he opened for us all, Bob saw his true vocation; to be a translator like his dad, what the tradition calls a Lokaschakshu—a world-eye.

While his peers were either rushing to escape the Titanic of the West with sex, drugs, and rock and roll, or vying for the best deck chairs on the most destructive siege engine in history, Bob was busy as Morpheus, guiding strays like you and me into the Kalachakra Time Machine, hidden in communion with everything.

Of course, like Morpheus, our hero was many things to many people. To me, first and foremost, he was the psychonaut who climbed to the source of the pure mountain stream—only drops of which had helped awaken my boyhood hero Carl Jung far away in his dusty library in Küsnacht. Being around Bob meant drinking that elixir stream from a firehose. That’s largely because, behind his stand-up humor and infectious joy, Bob was an otherworldly genius linguist-poet-philosopher. He made the subtlest, life-saving wisdom and the arts of Buddhist civilization speak to our broken hearts in their mother-tongues by pulling or coining just the right word from Western art, culture, philosophy, science, politics, or religion.

Last, but not least, for me Bob’s teaching was perfect because he was also a people-power activist. A freedom fighter, he worked to break his privileged audience out of the matrix of the American dream. He urged us to overthrow the toxic cult of materialism and supremacy through his “inner revolution.”

Watching Bob in action, as he connected with audiences of all backgrounds, in all kinds of settings, and multiple different languages, it was clear that the transformative impact he had on me was felt by countless others. The joy he took in the dharma, his fluency in all its genres, highlights, insights, and technicalities, his love of sharing it, and his unshakable faith in its power to transform us, made him the most inspirational dharma teacher anyone could imagine. Yet he was so much more than a dream teacher. Like the fierce wisdom deity Yamantaka, he seemed to have thirty-four arms, all working together at light-speed, wielding thirty-four different instruments of liberation.

Ever the tireless scholar, he founded the nation’s first chair in Tibetan studies, trained a whole generation of heirs in the living wisdom of Tibetan scholarship, launched the first project to systematically translate the whole Tengyur, the lost library of the Buddhist sciences of Indian and Tibet.  Yet he was never really at home in the constraints of Western academia. As a social entrepreneur, with Nena’s urging and guidance, he resurrected Tibet House U.S. and founded the Medicine Buddha Pure Land of Menla Mountain Retreat. But his most powerful dynamism emerged when he set the diamond drill of his mind to work, tapping into the hidden treasure of an untranslated Sanskrit or Tibetan text.

As the spiritual friend of celebrities, like those he and Nena gathered together for their annual Carnegie Hall benefit concerts, he was a prodigious advocate of freedom for the people and culture of Tibet. But he was most himself reading and writing in the cozy, book-lined office of his handmade house in Woodstock. As “the Dalai Lama’s Man in America,” he maintained an intimate bond as a close student, friend, and ally of the world’s favorite leader ever since the day they met. But his secret guide—the one he called his guruni—was his partner in all things, Nena.

Of course, we are all in awe of this bull of a man with a drum-like voice who touched so many hearts and minds, but the one great work that made him my perfect teacher was the inner devotion he showed while applying himself to becoming a better human. What most people don’t know of Bob is the man behind the wizard.

The son of a powerfully driven family whose roots go back to a long line of generals and colonial settlers in Virginia, our teacher felt a crushing burden: exorcising the ghosts of the past, and meeting great expectations to do bold things. As often happpens  when such drive  is not held by mentors with wisdom and kindness, it wreaked havoc in Bob’s’s life until he met the teachers who could provide that holding.

The secret ingredient at work at the heart of Bob, the man, was the alchemy that turned his disruptive drive into gratitude. He was grateful for the human care that harnessed his genius for the collective good. Given that alchemy, those of us who knew him up close saw the pressure he had felt gradually give way, turning his diamond-in-the-rough humanity into real diamond. This was the nature of his inner devotion to Geshe Wangyal and His Holiness; and explains why, while the majority of his peers—eminent scholars, artists, celebrities, men of the world—were getting more and more caught up in themselves and their outward success, Bob was coming out of himself. He became kinder, more patient, more forgiving. He spoke more gently and sweetly, and, believe it or not, he even spoke more simply. This is the kind of quiet revolution we need in the crisis of today.

My experience with him over fifty-three years was my test case. Even after I had disappointed him several times—first by going into psychiatry and then by leaving the academy after my PhD to found Nalanda Institute—not only did he embrace my choices, but he joined in to teach alongside me. He touched the lives of all of the Institute’s students from its founding in 2003 until his last day. Bob was truly a man on a mission to challenge, help, and heal. I believe that’s why—despite studying with him for ten full years, teaching with him for twenty, and reading nearly everything he wrote—every single time I had the good fortune to hear him speak or teach alongside him, I heard something truer, clearer, and more freeing than before.

For me, all this is encapsulated in the last teaching of his that popped into my Instagram feed just weeks before he passed: “The ultimate reality cannot be found,” he said, “but it can be lived.”

Well, my friend, you lived it, and you showed us all how it’s done. Thank you for saving my life more than once. And thank you for opening the door to inconceivable liberation. In whatever form and place you’ve willed your return, I know it was carefully chosen to carry your vision down through the generations, for as long as it takes our human family to wake up and restore our Mother Earth to the Kalachakra medicine planet you envisioned and lived for. Om Mani Padme Hum Hrii! Om Ara Pacana Dhi!

by Joe Loizzo

“Seekers, the mind is naturally luminous and pure, its afflictions are not intrinsic.”
—Shakyamuni Buddha, Anguttara Nikaya

These days, when the fear-based, othering narratives our cultures have used to control us get more nakedly exposed as lies every day, I’m spending as much of my time as I can trying to leverage the crisis all the lies have fomented into a pivotal opportunity. I’ve been encouraging everyone I can to wake up from the original big lie: that we’re not enough, not good enough, don’t know enough, are not young, rich or powerful enough; that we need leaders and must be followers; that the people we call leaders have to lead us from a place of fear, anger and bias, a place that separates us from our loving selves, from others and from the earth we share. 

That awakening sounds easy: we’re more than enough, somewhere inside us is an inner Buddha/guide that is naturally brilliant, naturally good. But what I’ve learned in offering that good news to myself and others is that it’s not so easy for us to find that part of us that can really take it in. So why is that amazing news so hard to believe, to feel? Because it requires a sober confrontation with what Shakyamuni Buddha considered our worst demon: the instinctive social survival drive Freud called infantile narcissism, the wish to be forever the child of an all-knowing, all-powerful higher power/God.

This primal insecurity/longing is the stubborn, insidious demon that, when preyed on by sociopaths, can possess individuals to make other humans their higher power, and can possess whole groups, giving rise to imperialism, fascism, totalitarianism, and supremacies of all kinds. It is the demon that seduces us into the blind faith that we cannot and need not all lead ourselves; the wishful thinking that somehow something outside us—God, Nature, the Supreme Leader, the “invisible hand” of capitalism, the idols of wealth, fame or power, the next technology, AI—can save us from our own demons or grant us true freedom and happiness.

Of course, waking up to the lie is not enough for us to shift out of self-doubt into self-confidence and basic trust. Now is the time to take refuge in the truth of the many countercultures throughout history and around the world that have sought to empower us to lead ourselves, others, and our lives from our creative powers of love, joy and awe. Countercultures like Buddhist psychology, our many mystical and indigenous wisdom traditions, today’s positive neuropsychology and the new science of human flourishing all affirm our natural capacity to live sustained by awe, love and care for all life, starting with our own.

This is where we are now, in the global crisis of our age, hopefully at another great turning point in human history. It’s time for us to break with the dominant narratives and toxic leaders who prey on the fear, bias and anger that separate us from our true selves, one another and the planet. It’s time to keep reminding ourselves that we have what we need, as long as we can remember to mind/let go of the traumatized part of us that reflexively clings to feeling helpless, powerless and small. 

It’s time we commit to seeking out, feeling into and embodying the strong forces of love and awe that are our birthright and native genius—forces that for too long have been locked down in the core of our being. And it’s time to admit to ourselves and each other that no other path, pursuit or remedy but deepening our refuge in reality/community and intensifying the seriousness of our analysis and practice can empower us to successfully navigate this pivotal turn. 

Only owning and learning to be/live the truth of our native brilliance and goodness can free us to thrive as individuals and together as one human family—to co-create a sustainable, equitable future of earthly belonging and mutual responsibility for all. Once we awaken and own our inner guide—both as individuals and as a countercultural community of care—nothing can stop us but the demon of our own sense of powerlessness.

by Joe Loizzo

Joe Loizzo, Dr. Nida Chenagtsang, trauma, tantra, tantric healing, Tibetan medicine, embodied wisdom

After the better part of a lifetime spent exploring the historic confluence of today’s emerging mind science with the timeless healing traditions of Buddhist psychology, my experience teaching in dialogue with the inspiring faculty of our Certificate Program in Embodied Wisdom feels like the fruition of a dream come true. For the past fifteen years, I’ve been privileged to join beloved scholar-practitioners like Sharon Salzberg and Jan Willis, leading psychotherapists like Pilar Jennings and Janina Fisher, neuroscientists like Richie Davidson and David Vago, and visionaries like Jasmine Syedullah and Lama Rod Owens on an unprecedented multi-disciplinary, inter-traditional journey into the incredibly liberating and enlightening interchange between the Nalanda tradition of Buddhist contemplative science and the latest breakthroughs in contemporary psychotherapy, neuropsychology and social psychology/psychosocial change. 

For the first twelve years, the focus of our journey together has been on the foundational teachings and practices of Buddhist psychology, through year-long certificate programs Mindfulness, Insight and Care and in Wise Compassion. But over the last three years, this historic interchange has culminated in the Certificate Program in Embodied Wisdom, the most unique and unprecedented final phase of this promising dialogue. The program in Embodied Wisdom explores the confluence between the healing arts and sciences of the Tibetan Tantras and today’s innovative embodied trauma therapies. At the heart of this program is our dialogue with one of the leading exponents of Tibetan Tantric medicine and psychiatry, Dr. Nida Chenagtsang. 

Teaching with Dr. Nida for me feels like sharing with a long-lost brother from the other side of history and the planet. Raised and educated in the Mongolian part of Eastern Tibet, Dr. Nida has become an innovative, international voice for the unique tradition of Tibetan medicine which focuses on embodied Tantric healing and transformation, the tradition founded by Yuthog Yonten Gonpo (1127-1203). What makes our dialogue so invigorating and rewarding for me is that Dr. Nida is both deeply rooted in his tradition and fascinated and actively engaged in dialogue with Western psychology, neuroscience and psychotherapy. As a contemplative psychotherapist rooted in Western neuropsychology and actively engaged in lifelong dialogue with Tibetan healing arts and sciences, when I teach with Dr. Nida it feels like speaking to my mirror image or alter ego. 

Given how deeply resonant and gratifying this dialogue has been for me personally, I’m thrilled to be able to share with you an excerpt from a Spring retreat we offered together at Tibet House US, From Fire to Light: Completion Stage Yogas for Transforming Trauma. The focus of the Spring retreat in the Embodied Wisdom Program is on a form of embodied insight meditation known as Atiyoga, a.k.a. Dzogchen or Mahamudra. 

This tradition has become increasingly popular in the West, in large part because its promise of offering the quickest path to liberating, healing wisdom naturally appeals to our quick-fix, consumerist mindset. Unfortunately, this has also meant that this most profound and most distilled version of Buddhist meditation on the non-dual wisdom of emptiness has become even more prone to spiritual bypassing in our day than it was in Yuthog’s Tibet. 

This may explain why I so appreciate teaching this subtlest of subtleties with Dr. Nida, who shares my concern to ground this liberating, healing wisdom in the embodied reality of our everyday lives and the complex neuropsychology of feeling into and breaking free of trauma, individually and collectively. Although it may be challenging to drop into the final dialogue of this final weekend teaching, it is my sincere hope that the excerpt we’ve shared will give you a taste of the incredible promise that has drawn me to this tradition and this work for so many rewarding years.


Editor’s note: Dr. Nida is the Meditation Mentor in the Embodied Wisdom year of our Contemplative Psychotherapy Program, of which retreats are an integral part. Our next cohort launches September 26, 2025. Whether you are a clinician, caregiver of any kind, teacher, or a passionate seeker of the deeper wisdom this tradition has to offer, we warmly welcome you to join us.

Learn more and apply now

We are happy to share with you a brief glimpse of a recent Nalanda Institute Contemplative Psychotherapy three-day retreat “Inconceivable Liberation: The Non-Dual Wisdom and Art of Growing Beloved Community” at Tibet House US. This excerpt features an intriguing dialogue between Dr. Jasmine Syedullah, professor and co-author of Radical Dharma: Talking Race, Love, and Liberation, and Dr. Joe Loizzo, Academic Director of the Nalanda Institute.

Weaving together the prophetic voices of contemporary Black feminist writer Audre Lorde and lay Buddhist social visionary Vimalakirti, Jasmine and Joe evoke the striking and inspiring resonance that emerges between these liberative traditions from opposite ends of history and the planet. In these excerpts from the culminating sessions of the retreat, the teachers and an intimate global community gathered together to revel in tasting the liberation of radical open-mindedness and the embodied joy and power of love unleashed when we break the death-grip of supremacist cultures and the traumatic way of life they lock us in.

Retreats are an integral element of Nalanda Institute’s Contemplative Psychotherapy Program (CPP). This retreat was part of the 2024/25 year of study in CPP’s Certificate in Wise Compassion.

Editor’s Note:
Nalanda Institute’s Contemplative Psychotherapy Program (CPP) is a three-year journey through Mindfulness, Insight and Care; Wise Compassion; and Embodied Wisdom. 

This fall—soon—we are offering the Certificate in Wise Compassion in English and Spanish / Portuguese; and the Certificate in Embodied Wisdom in English. To learn more and apply: https://nalandainstitute.org/cpp-uber-2026-2027.

A Note from Joe Loizzo on What Makes the Nalanda Tradition Special

by Joe Loizzo

Nalanda University

What sets the tradition developed at Nalanda University and preserved in Tibet apart from other Buddhist traditions taught in Asia and the West? On his deathbed, the Buddha urged his heirs to not just preserve his teaching and practice but to keep improving on them. The tradition of scientific teaching (abhidharma) to fulfill that directive found its home in the world’s first university at Nalanda, founded explicitly to advance Buddhist science and civilization through dialogue with all the secular arts and sciences of India. Eventually, that unique mission made Nalanda a beacon of contemplative learning that influenced all Asia, and was most fully preserved in Tibet, leading His Holiness the Dalai Lama to refer to Tibetan Buddhism as “the Nalanda tradition.”

Uniquely, the Nalanda tradition includes the full range of psychologies it takes to engage with the whole spectrum of Western psychotherapies, from analytic, relational, and intersubjective to cognitive, depth psychology, and the positive psychology of human flourishing. No other tradition integrates Buddhist medicine and psychiatry in ways that allow a deep dialogue with Western neuroscience and neuropsychology. And no other tradition includes a comprehensive vision and practice of healing, social development, and radical psychosocial change that can support a robust exchange with contemporary social psychology, social neuroscience, and social justice practice. 

While most Buddhist traditions around the world were designed for and by monastics, the Nalanda tradition was designed by social visionaries Nagarjuna and Asanga as a diverse, open community where monastic and lay members could meet and exchange ideas and practices. While most Buddhist traditions mainly focus on meditative practice, the Nalanda curriculum and its scholar-practitioners is equally focused on intellectual interchange and innovation in medicine, neuropsychology, social policy, and the expressive arts. And while most Buddhist communities disengage from the world to look inward, the Nalanda community was and remains socially engaged and transformational in its mission and vision. All of these distinctive aspects make the Nalanda tradition ideal for Western student-practitioners seeking to weave Buddhist wisdom and healing arts into their everyday life and work in the world. 


Editor’s note: If you’d like to explore the healing power of mindfulness, loving kindness, and Buddhist wisdom and want to go deeper and wider in your search for a radical alternative to the destructive materialist culture of our age, please consider joining Nalanda Institute’s unique Contemplative Psychotherapy Program for our three-year journey—or the year of study that calls to you—through the breadth and depth of the Nalanda tradition. 

Courses in English and Spanish/Portuguese begin this September, 2025!

Photo above: The ancient Nalanda Monastery — the world’s first residential university in Bihar, India, established around 427 CE.

Celebrating His Holiness the 14th Dalai Lama on his 90th Birthday

by Joe Loizzo

[download the full article in PDF format]

The first time I had the good fortune to be in His Holiness the Dalai Lama’s presence was in the fall of 1981, on his second visit to the U.S. It was at the Deer Park Buddhist Center in the rural town of Oregon, Wisconsin, where some 1,500 people from around the world had gathered inside a huge striped tent pitched in an open field, to attend the first ever empowerment for the Clockwork Process (Kalachakra-tantra) outside India and Tibet. 

The atmosphere was electric, as people buzzed in anticipation of the teaching. Even though the Clockwork was supposedly a top-secret, embodied contemplative practice—an Unexcelled Yoga Tantra—like the ones I’d been introduced to in India and Woodstock, the gathering was unlike any I’d experienced before. Instead of being offered exclusively to monastics, or in an intimate group far removed from the everyday world, this empowerment overwhelmingly attracted lay people—lay Tibetans in their hand-made turquoise jewelry and vibrant, traditional dress, and a United Nations of people speaking languages from around the world. It felt as if we were part of a historic, planetary event, a movement of like-minded spirits from all backgrounds converging to share an otherworldly experience, like a global version of the motley crew that came together in Stephen Spielberg’s science-fiction film classic, Close Encounters of the Third Kind. 

At the time, the Dalai Lama was an obscure Buddhist leader from the most remote, off-the-grid nation in the world, actually living as a refugee in a small town in the Himalayan foothills of North India. I knew of him thanks to my scholarly mentor Robert (“Tenzin Bob”) Thurman, the first Western Tibetan monk, who had developed a close friendship with His Holiness during and after his monastic studies in India in the sixties. For the last eight years, Bob had patiently guided me through the whole Tibetan curriculum, starting with the basic liberative science of Buddhist psychology, moving through the profound depths and universal vision of its world-changing path of non-dual wise compassion, and culminating in the richly symbolic arts and subtle neuropsychology of embodied transformation called the Unexcelled Yoga Tantras.

Eventually, my journey with Bob led to India, where he introduced me to three Tantric scholar-practitioners who would become my mentors of embodied ethics, meditation, and wisdom: the late Ngawang Gelek Rimpoche, and two of the Dalai Lama’s own tutors, the 6th Yongdzin Ling Rimpoche and the 1st Tsanzhab Serkhong Rimpoche. It was from Ling and Serkong Rimpoche that I received the two empowerments that traditionally form the foundation of Tantric practice in the Dalai Lama’s “Yellow Hat” Ge-lugs school. Yet it was not until receiving the Clockwork empowerment that summer on Turtle Island from the Dalai Lama that I knew my entry into the profound and impactful lineage of Tibetan Buddhism was complete. Here’s why.

 

His Holiness the Spiritual Scientist

Commonly, this Dalai Lama, like his predecessors, is seen as a voluntary incarnation of the archetypal awakened altruist Avalokiteshvara, “the pure being who watches over” all life with unconditional love and compassion. In particular, the Dalai Lamas are revered and beloved as special incarnations of Avalokiteshvara devoted to protecting and caring for Tibet and the Tibetan people. In contrast, the archetype of the Clockwork Process, the archetype His Holiness was incarnating in that field in Wisconsin, is not one of compassion pure and simple, nor is it dedicated exclusively or primarily to protecting Tibet. 

The Clockwork archetype represents a uniquely historical form of compassion emanated by Shakyamuni himself, at the behest of a Central Asian ruler said to be an incarnation of the wisdom archetype Manjushri. Specifically, he represents a very particular form of wise compassion devoted to protecting the whole human race and planet Earth itself from war, sectarian violence, and economic/political oppression. Even more uncharacteristic is the way he is committed to accomplishing this vow: not by fostering a global spiritual movement towards universal love and compassion, but by advancing a human science (vidya) of embodied wisdom and compassion that explains how spirituality works, and links it with a contemplative technology which makes it universally accessible and reproducible. 

Given all my knowledge and experience of the Dalai Lama since that first encounter, it is this archetype—of the advancement of the science and technology of human self-transformation—that I believe touches most intimately on the awakened genius, mission and impact which this self-described “ordinary human being” and “simple Buddhist monk” has brought to the world in his ninety years on earth. 

This uncommon take on His Holiness and his unique genius may seem to clash with the religious devotion in which so many hold the man, a devotion that has only grown as his clear, helpful teachings and joyful spirit have spread his fame globally, making him one of the most admired and trusted people of our day. It certainly challenges our deeply ingrained modern bias that spirituality and science, timeless wisdom and the latest technology are completely at odds, like oil and water, and can’t mix harmoniously in one human being, much less one human culture or civilization. 

On the other hand, it would explain why the teenage Lhamo Thondub, a.k.a. Tenzin Gyatso the Dalai Lama, annoyed his tutors by wasting so much of his time picking apart and putting back together the few mechanical devices that came his way, from mechanical toys to Swiss watches, movie projectors to old cars. It would also explain why he spent hours on end as a young leader in exile in Dharamsala picking my former professor’s brain for every detail Bob could recall from his Harvard gen-ed classes on physics, biology, and neuroscience. And last but not least, it would also explain why the Dalai Lama made it a centerpiece of his life’s mission to carry on a dialogue with Western scientists which would spawn groundbreaking new fields of research on the science of meditation, mindfulness, compassion and human flourishing, including contemplative neuroscience, contemplative education and contemplative psychotherapy.  

Joe Loizzo and the Dalai Lama

H.H. the Dalai Lama greets Joe Loizzo in 2017 in India.

 

Dialogues in Science: When East Meets West

As someone lucky enough to have participated in many of these dialogues, starting with the first on Mind Science at Amherst College in 1986, I’ve heard His Holiness make countless comments one would never expect from a lifelong contemplative or spiritual leader. A few of these in particular may offer a window for you, as they did for me, onto the unexpected way his out-of-the-box brilliance works. 

In one conference I helped organize at Beth Israel’s Hospital for Neurosurgery in 1999, he was listening to my co-convener Dr. William Bushell unpack the neurochemistry of meditation and healing when he ribbed, “I’d be more than happy to stop doing my daily practice, if you could only make an enlightenment pill!” At Columbia in 2005, after expressing my frustration that the science validating the healing power of contemplative methods was still facing stubborn resistance among my colleagues in neuroscience and medicine, His Holiness commiserated by sharing how disappointed he was that so many of his senior monastic teachers still denied the validity of Western astronomy, physics and biology, “They still insist that the moon is a self-luminous body,” he complained. At yet another conference at MIT in 2003, he shocked the assembled audience by flatly proclaiming: “If science proves some belief of Buddhism wrong, then Buddhism will have to change.” 

This is not to say that His Holiness believes Western science is sufficient in itself, or superior in general to Buddhist science. Far from it. Yet so much is made by researchers and journalists alike of his sustained interest in the science of the West that many in the scientific community and general public have the impression that he shares their parochial faith in its exclusive validity and intrinsic superiority. 

The truth was clear as day to me from the start of these conferences, simply from looking and listening as the Dalai Lama and his colleagues, including translator Thubten Jinpa, exchanged ironic glances, smiles, or quips in Tibetan when some Western scientists presented with a stuffy air of utter seriousness, certainty and authority. Having watched Tibetan monks train for hours debating the nuances of seven complete systems of cosmology, biology and physics with all the playful exuberance and raucous humor of teenagers in a close game of basketball, I knew His Holiness and his entire team could shoot holes in every certainty they heard, just as a sharp Western philosopher of science or quantum physicist might. 

To my great satisfaction, my intuition was borne out at the same 2005 conference at Columbia I mentioned, when in the follow-up to my presentation on the global contribution of the Tibetan sciences, the Dalai Lama did what I had long hoped he would. He articulated in no uncertain terms what I’ve assumed for many years: that while Western physical science was far more advanced than its Buddhist analogues, the same could be said of Buddhist psychology compared with its Western counterparts. I would also add that, given that a universal relativity theory was woven into Buddhist science two thousand years before it was developed in the West, Buddhist scientists are generally more advanced in their critical understanding of the nature and limits of science than their colleagues in the West. Later in his own summary comments, His Holiness affirmed his conviction, “Buddhist psychology for the mind, and Tibetan medicine for the body; these are the precious gifts of Tibetan civilization to the future of humankind.” 

 

The Embodied Science of Conscious Evolution

Which brings us back to the Clockwork Process, with its seamless integration of Buddhist psychology, Tibetan medicine, and the multi-disciplinary Tantric science of human transformation. It makes sense that the Dalai Lama prized the centuries-old Indian sciences of Buddhist psychology and medicine refined in Tibet as his civilization’s greatest contributions to humanity, but why embed these two within the Buddhist Tantras, as the Clockwork system does? The Tantric Buddhism of Tibet—with its elaborate universe of mythic symbols and ritual arts—appears to be the least scientific, most religious form of Buddhism to emerge in its millennia of historical development and spread. 

As with the mythic archetypes and devotional rituals of Mahayana Buddhism and the strict monastic discipline and meditative practice of early Theravada Buddhism, at the heart of all Buddhist traditions, including the Tantras, lies a scientific psychology and transformational method that traditional scholar-practitioners such as His Holiness recognize as the essence of Buddhism. The reason the embodied neuropsychology of the Tantras became the preferred technological matrix for classical Buddhist psychology and medicine in their final unfolding was that this form of Buddhist science was widely acknowledged as the most rigorous and effective method for realizing the Buddha’s aim: liberating the human mind, body and community from the bondage of life driven by the evolutionary cycle of stress and trauma. 

Of course, from the outside, one would never guess the scientific logic and life-transforming technology powering the Tantras. Which explains why untutored witnesses, including Western scholars, have routinely mistaken Tibet’s Tantric psychology and medicine for prescientific superstition and empty, ritual magic. Even initiated practitioners, Western and Eastern, commonly focus on the colorful, imaginative, and ritual surface of the practice rather than dig deeper into the subtle neuropsychological core that makes the practice work. This is no accident. 

Most Tantric systems were explicitly designed to shroud the deeper science and technology that powers them in layers of symbolism and rite meant to hide the more challenging truths and advanced practices in secrecy, until practitioners are fully prepared. Unlike these other systems, the Clockwork is designed expressly to demystify this potent technology, making it readily available to the lay mainstream of all diverse human societies on planet Earth. Instead of safeguarding its practices from misunderstanding and misuse through hermetic symbolism and secrecy, the Clockwork took the strategy of safeguarding them by explaining the science behind them.

This thousand-year-old strategy for spreading the transformational science and healing arts of the Tantras to a global audience explains why His Holiness chose the Clockwork system as his way to reach out to the larger world, including his audience of curious seekers in the West.  In this light, it’s also clear why he has invested so much time and effort in dialogue with Western scientists. 

 

Shakyamuni’s Contemplative Science and Nalanda

As for those concerned he is breaking with Buddhist tradition and conceding too much by committing to give up teachings that conflict with current science, think again. Truth is, the traditional Buddhist relationship with science—whether physical, biological, or social—since Shakyamuni’s day has seen scientific theories and methods very much as contemporary philosophers of science do: as provisional knowledge that invariably will need to be modified in different contexts and revised as new findings or better theories arise. 

The only science regarded as ultimately reliable in this tradition is the timeless, contemplative science (adhyatama-vidya) of developing a radically free, open heart and mind. So historically, across all the civilizations that have hosted it, the Buddhist tradition has adopted the most current, widely accepted sciences as a working model of reality, much as other religious traditions have adopted local mythologies. Of course, following Shakyamuni’s lead, Buddhist traditions have regarded even the best physical and social sciences not as revealed, unchanging truths, but as humanly constructed, provisional best models, to be continually tested and revised by critical reason and direct evidence. 

This is why, when the Buddha taught, he insisted his students analyze his words critically and accept them only “…as a goldsmith buys gold, after weighing, examining and testing, not out of faith in me.” And it is also why, when it came time to honor him, his followers did so not by praising his compassion, his meditative prowess, or even his philosophical profundity, but his discovery of the developmental causality that empowered him and his heirs to break the death-grip of the evolutionary cycle of stress and trauma. 

So it should come as no surprise that, on his deathbed, Shakyamuni enjoined his followers not to preserve his teachings (dharma) simply but to improve on them by creating a super-teaching (abhi-dharma) which many current scholars translate as a “scientific teaching.” That progressive project became the mission of the great Buddhist colleges and universities of India, which continued to develop Buddhist psychology and medicine for over 1,500 years, especially Nalanda University, whose motto explicitly honored Buddha for his scientific discovery of cause and effect. 

It is this academic tradition, which centered the scientific foundation of Buddhist teaching, ethics, and practice, that became the source of all four schools of Tibetan Buddhism. That is why His Holiness has moved in recent decades to speaking of the Tibetan Buddhist tradition as the Nalanda tradition. And it is also why the vanguard of that tradition is the Clockwork system, which unveils the Tantric form that Buddhism took at Nalanda University as a multi-disciplinary science of individual and collective transformation and flourishing. 

So, in committing to replace any elements of Buddhist science disconfirmed by current Western science, and in presenting the Tantric Buddhism of Tibet in its most scientifically clear and cogent form, the Dalai Lama has in no way departed from Buddhist tradition but has, in fact, been entirely faithful to its foundation and essence.    

 

The Method Behind the Dalai Lama’s “Religion of Kindness”

This long backstory for His Holiness’ profound interest in Western science is not well recognized either by the scientists he dialogues with or by the general public. This is partly due to Western preconceptions of religious figures as leaders only in the realms of ethics, meditation, and the ritual arts, and partly due to the intentional way His Holiness presents himself so that as many as possible find him approachable. This is the real reason why he is widely seen as a paragon of kindness, humility, and human solidarity. Of course, he is a paragon of these sorely needed human virtues, but his putting that most approachable foot forward does not mean that it goes to the heart of who he is, or reflects the sum of what makes him tick. In truth, it is a painstakingly cultivated, artful expression of his deeper intent to build bridges that can help connect a global humanity fragmented by clashes between science and religion, by historic conflicts between different cultures and religions, and by widening gulfs between rich and poor nations and classes. 

Don’t get me wrong. It’s not that his humble, friendly affect is affected or unnatural to him. Many of us have witnessed him welling up with tears when speaking of a recent human tragedy in a teaching, and moments later guffawing with laughter at a joke exchanged with his senior teachers. He is notorious among his staff for seeing right through and poking fun at any pretense, be it spiritual piety or intellectual arrogance. So much so that they often struggle with his trickster tendency to disrupt solemn proceedings or tease starchy interlocutors, from the most seasoned journalists to world-renowned scientific experts. 

There is, of course, a method to the Dalai Lama’s kindness. His raw, emotional range and authenticity, as well as his radical acceptance of his own and others’ human vulnerability, have a powerful, disarming effect on those around him. Some accustomed to formality and hierarchy might find his presence childlike or naive. But there is nothing childish or naive about His Holiness. What comes across to anyone receptive at all is that this is a consummate human being, someone you’d love to have as a friend, colleague, parent, teacher, or neighbor. His radical humanity is a teaching in itself; it is a medicine for the frozen defensiveness that locks our true colors in a psychosocial and culturally imposed prison of bias, fear, and repression; it is a political act to challenge any and all hints of supremacy, hierarchy, or othering.

 

Back to the Future: The Science That Will Save Our Planet

The Dalai Lama may be an embodiment of an age-old scientific tradition, but this is not the cold, calculating, heartless science we are accustomed to. Just as he insists kindness without wisdom can easily lead to harm, he often warns those drawn to the elegance of Buddhist science that even the sharpest intellect is a prison for our humanity without the human spirit of love and compassion. This profound civilizing strategy, that knowledge and power must be guided by a radically open mind and unconditionally warm heart, lies at the very core of all Buddhist learning, all aspects of the Nalanda tradition, and their final culmination in the Clockwork system. 

It’s easy to see why most admirers of the Dalai Lama see him as an extraordinary exception, a lucky stroke of genetics or karma. But he insists he’s not exceptional at all, just an ordinary human, a simple Buddhist monk. I believe the truth lies somewhere in between. The missing variable is the scientific rigor and technical power of the Buddhist contemplative arts and sciences. 

The current research on exceptional performance shows human genius—scientific or spiritual—is not a function of genetics or talent, but of cultivation through lifelong learning and repeated practice. While we may balk at the idea that we could not just admire His Holiness but also grow to emulate him, that is the very essence of what he and the entire tradition he embodies assume and teach. Just imagine what this world would be if he were right, if we could have not just one Dalai Lama but billions, in every possible shape and size, color and gender, learning style and neural ability?

This is the logic of the prophetic—and challenging—vision the Clockwork offers us. What if, at the heart of all the education delivered in every culture around the world, we built in the human science of awakening and embodying radical open-mindedness, as well as unconditional love and compassion? 

What if we combined the science of human awakening with the symbolic imagination and contemplative practice of each and every human spiritual tradition? And what if we integrated that global patchwork of timeless human science into the core of each and every scientific, technological, and practical discipline it takes to run a complex global civilization like today’s? 

What if, beyond simply generating the incalculable knowledge, wealth, and power our culture accumulates minute by minute, every one of us and each institution and community everywhere on earth actually knew in their bones precisely what to do with it all? 

What if we had the wisdom, compassion, and technical skill to bring our present world back from the brink of Armageddon and extinction, one choice, one act at a time, and move it instead step by step towards the global flourishing of an equitable, sustainable human civilization? 

The prophetic, global vision the Clockwork presents is not just another utopian pipe dream. It is backed up by a know-how that has been tested and proven over thousands of years. His Holiness and the countless other remarkable Tibetan leaders trained in the same system are living proof that it works; just as their peers in other wisdom traditions—from Mahatma Gandhi, Dr. Martin Luther King, Pir Zia Inayat Kahn and Abraham Joshua Heschel to Black Elk, Desmond Tutu and countless others—are proof of what their humanizing systems of learning can do. 

In fact, the prophecy is not just backed up by the living proof of these remarkable beings but also now by a growing body of Western scientific evidence, thanks to the Dalai Lama’s patiently executed long game of engaging, inspiring, and directing a whole new generation of Western scientists through his ongoing dialogues. And, of course, it is also a vision consistent with the converging mass of data and models from the whole range of new complexity sciences, which show that seriously investing in our human flourishing on a global scale is the only viable path to a livable future for each and every one of us.

 

Clockwork Science and the Medicine Planet

In broad strokes, the Clockwork’s futuristic prophecy is that its perennial science and technology of awakening were preserved and improved in the time capsule of the kingdom of Shambhala, hidden somewhere in the Himalayan plateau. (I for one see this as a not-so-veiled reference to the mountain kingdom of Tibet, the greenhouse for the Nalanda tradition.) There it was to remain closely guarded until humanity’s warring factions were on the brink of destroying the planet. 

At that point, sometime in the coming century or so, it is said, the contemplative scientists (vidya-dhara) of Shambhala will emerge from hiding and disseminate the transformational science and technology of the Tantras worldwide, seeding a global human awakening and a genuine earthly utopia. This thousand-year-old prophecy was the basis for the black-and-white film classic Lost Horizons, which involves a journey to the lost, hyper-civilized mountain kingdom known as Shangrila.

 

Anantavijaya, the Scientist for All Life on Earth

Which brings me back to where and how I first encountered His Holiness. As I sat close to him for the first time, deeply touched and moved by his presence, and taking to heart the richly symbolic teachings he shared, I felt as if the Clockwork vision was speaking directly to me and the urgent mission guiding my life’s work, the mission that brought me there. 

The very idea of a culture dedicated to reconciling science and spirituality, applying a poetically envisioned, neuropsychologically based contemplative science and practice to shift the course of civilization towards altruistic awakening and embodied compassion—that was my dream come true. More appealing still, this inspiring vision was not offered as a dead, disembodied ideal but as a fully embodied, smiling way of being and living, incarnated by scholar-practitioners like His Holiness and Serkhong Rimpoche, his own Clockwork mentor.  

So this is who the Dalai Lama was and still is for me: the next-to-last Shambhala leader (kalki) Anantavijaya, like one of the luminous aliens in Close Encounters, signaling and embodying the way forward for me, my colleagues, and for all humanity. A living, breathing, friendly beacon for our wisdom-blind age. Over the years, the more I got to know him personally through his dialogues with Western scientists, the more I realized how—invisibly, uncannily—our scientific dialogue with Tibetan science and civilization was definitely going both ways. The Clockwork practice, which has grown in me and a widening circle of planetary citizens the world over these forty-some years, is that music of the spheres which is the eye-opening voice and telepathic wake-up call of Tibet’s life-changing science and world-transforming healing arts.

 

Happy Birthday, Cent’Anni!

Your Holiness, in honor of the incomparable gift you have offered your own people, the global Buddhist community and the whole world through your selfless 88 years of learning, practice and teaching, we at Nalanda Institute would like to wish you an incomparably happy 90th and many many more years of perfect vitality, health and well-being. As our humble offering, we hereby pledge to remember and try our daily best to embody the truth of your favorite prayer, from Shantideva’s Introduction to the Awakened Altruist’s Life: 

“May I be the doctor, 

And the medicine, 

And also the nurse

Until all beings are healed!

For as long as space endures,

And as long as living beings remain,

Until then may I (too) remain

To dispel the suffering of the world.” 

Last but not least, as my long-lived Italian relatives would do, we wish you a hundred years, “Cent’anni!” 

by Joe Loizzo

Election Day Meditation

Dear Friends,

As we brace to hear the results of a hotly contested, deeply consequential election, we have an opportunity to strengthen one of the most protective and beneficial muscles in our embodied minds: equanimity.

While the survival drive that anchors our traumatic way of being is rooted in our instincts for self-
enclosure, separation, and duality—self or other, life or death, good or bad—the thriving mode that frees us to open our hearts and minds and to engage the full complexity of our lives and world, is rooted in the soil of our connective social capacities for love, compassion, gratitude, and equanimity.

Equanimity holds the wisdom of connection—the wisdom that helps expose and release the deathgrip of self-protective instincts, self-enclosing identities, and rigid worldviews by keeping us open to others and their unique needs, lived identities, and distinctive worldviews. It reminds us that holding any fixed, binary position fuels opposition, that fixated attachment to any binary outcome locks us into a rigid mindset and way of being prey to what are called the Eight Worldly Winds: clinging to comfort and fighting discomfort; attachment to winning and aversion to losing; seeking praise and rejecting criticism; clinging to celebrity and avoiding censure. In the Mahayana tradition, the social scope of the worldly winds is emphasized: clinging to good things for our loved ones and in-group while wishing the opposite for our challengers or out-group. Equanimity is the medicine that allows us to move through these winds without being thrown off center and off balance—to be open, resilient, flexible, and responsive enough to stay connected to all beings and to the infinite complexity of things in a continuous, unwavering way.


Editor’s note:

May this meditation support all beings everywhere in the pursuit of their ongoing practice of equanimity while being fully present to the complexity within ourselves, within those around us, and the world we collectively share.

by Joe Loizzo

For the last twenty years, it has been a privilege and a joy to lead a Program in Contemplative Self-Healing for breast cancer survivors at Weill Cornell Medical College in New York City. Despite dramatic gains in cancer care, most of these women struggle with post-traumatic stress syndrome after their treatment. This syndrome has long gone unnoticed and unaddressed by conventional oncology and makes their recovery far more challenging than it needs to be. In these groups, 25–35 women who have completed treatment learn and share together in an open healing community how mindfulness, compassion, imagery, and breath practices help them navigate the vital transition from simply surviving their cancer to thriving at a new level of well-being. It has been a transformative experience for me to be facilitating these groups of incredible women over the years, tasting the healing alchemy that takes place between them, and witnessing how some graduates have returned year after year to welcome anxious newcomers into their open and uplifting contemplative community.

This fall brought another opportunity for my research partner at Weill Cornell, leading oncologist Dr. Anne Moore and I to share the latest findings of the program with fellow cancer researchers from around the world. The conference, held in the charming Dutch city of Maastricht, was hosted by the International Psycho-Oncology Society, a unique organization that brings together mental health professionals and oncologists to go beyond simply treating cancer to improving the overall health, quality of life and well-being of the people living with and/or recovering from it. While the dedicated researchers and clinicians we met made the conference truly inspiring, it was sobering for us to confront once again how very far behind our U.S. medical system is in recognizing and seriously addressing this vital need. 

Our poster presentation reviewed the research Dr. Moore and I have been doing over the years at the Breast Cancer Survivorship Program at the Iris Cantor Women’s Center at the Weill Cornell Medical College along with the rest of our team, Nalanda Institute board member Dr. Mary Charlson, Rosio Ramos, and Dr. Robin Andrews of the Weill Cornell Division of Epidemiology. The ten-week Contemplative Self-Healing Program based on the Compassion-Based Resilience Training (CBRT) I developed over 25 years ago at Columbia Presbyterian Hospital, has been found in multiple pilot studies conducted at Weill Cornell and Montefiore Einstein as of 2003 (see Editor’s Note below to read the pilot studies), to significantly improve the quality of life and reduce the post-traumatic stress symptoms of women recovering from breast cancer. 

Our poster presentation also distilled the latest article to come out of our teamwork, showing that the program initially offered in person at Cornell has been effectively delivered online, co-hosted by Nalanda Institute, since the COVID 19 pandemic in 2020. The poster itself features some of the inspiring quotes of program participants, drawn from the qualitative analysis of their unstructured comments done by Dr. Andrews. Here are just a few of the comments participants shared about their experience in the program, which we included in the poster:

“It is superb. It is such a wonderful way for people to be together to express how they wish to grow to comfort each other and give insight into each other to gain knowledge and experience meditation together.”

“I now know that using what I’ve learned in the program,  I can help to stop/reduce my feelings of stress. That is very empowering. I now try to recognize early on when I am becoming over-stressed and implement what I’ve learned.”
 
“Much of the benefit of these sessions has been about unlearning old ways of handling stress and anxiety. The first step in unlearning is to notice. Through these sessions…I have derived tremendous strength and faith in myself (and my ability) to work through anxiety and stress.”
 
“I feel that meditation, particularly when I have maintained the practice, has really made me much more self-reflective and less stressed, both emotionally and physically.”

My heartfelt thanks to Drs. Moore and Charlson for having the fierce compassion to champion and support this much-needed work for the last twenty years, and of course, to the hundreds of wise and brave women who have allowed me to accompany them on their journey to full recovery and greater well-being.


Editor’s Note: 

If you’re interested in learning more and/or participating in this program, reach out to Rosio Ramos

Learn more about Weill Cornell’s Breast Center Survivorship Program

Check out the poster presented at the conference 

Read the pilot study: Contemplative Self healing in Women Breast Cancer Survivors: A Pilot Study in Underserved Minority Women Shows Improvement in Quality of Life and Reduced Stress

View results from this pilot study: Stress and Response to Treatment: Insights From a Pilot Study Using a 4-week Contemplative Self-Healing Meditation Intervention for Posttraumatic Stress in Breast Cancer

Learn more about Nalanda Institute’s Compassion-Based Resilience Training (CBRT), upon which the Contemplative Self-Healing Program conducted at the Iris Cantor Breast Cancer Center Survivorship Program is based on, or about Nalanda Institute’s CBRT Teacher Training. 

by Joe Loizzo, MD, PhD

Love and compassion are necessities not luxuries.
Without them humanity cannot survive.

—HH, the Dalai Lama

As a Buddhist psychotherapist and member of a diverse community focused on psychological healing, East and West, my heart is broken over the ongoing catastrophe in the Middle East that began with the Hamas attack on October 7th, 2023. I grapple with how to be helpful to our community, our kin in Gaza and Israel, and our larger human family at this crucial time. Tragically, just when those in the line of fire and those of us witnessing the death and destruction from afar most need to come together as an extended human family to provide protection, aid and care, we find ourselves caught up in the very divisions that have fueled the Middle East conflict over the last century. Given the polarizing atmosphere surrounding this crisis, it is not easy to engage in deep conversation around what is happening without aggravating those divisions, along with the othering and traumatic reactivity they activate. At the same time, saying nothing in the face of the horrific attack of October 7th and the genocidal violence and exponential loss of innocent civilian life in Gaza feels abandoning and inhuman.

[download the full article in PDF format]

 In sharing this reflection, it is my heartfelt wish to trace the deep roots of this conflict, in the hopes that it may help open the door to the kind of dialogue we need to stop the violence once and for all and move towards reconciliation. I also hope to share my daily practice of holding the ongoing tragedy while working through my own traumatic reactivity, so that I can resist the tendency towards othering, cut to the root causes of the harm taking place, and learn whether and how I might be of genuine help. This work feels doubly challenging since I teach and do psychotherapy with people whose lived experience sensitizes them to the pain of this tragedy as seen from diverse, seemingly incompatible points of view. 

Tracing the Roots

How (and Why) the Christian Colonial West Turned Jews and Muslims Against Each Other

What are the root causes of today’s devastating war in Gaza? As an immigrant whose Sicilian ancestors farmed for tens of thousands of years just a few hours from Palestine, I see the people on both sides of this conflict as my kin. As a student of history, I know that Muslims and Jews have generally lived peacefully as neighbors under Islamic law for most of the last two millennia, including four centuries in Sicily and thirteen in Palestine. I also know that the two main targets of white Christian Europe’s genocidal violence prior to the modern era of world colonization were my Muslim and Jewish kin. I know that when Jews were expelled from England, France, Spain, Russia, Germany, Italy and the Austro-Hungarian Empire in the centuries before Europe’s global colonization, many were welcomed to settle in the Islamic countries of North Africa, Anatolia and the Middle East.

In my mind, this history raises an obvious question. Since Palestinians and Jews not only peacefully co-existed for centuries, sharing a common enemy in Christian Europe, but also share closely related languages, ethnic origins, genetic legacies and spiritual roots, how did they come to be locked in so violent and intractable a conflict over the last three generations? As a newcomer to the U.S. in the 1960’s, struck by the deep divides I witnessed between groups that seemed like natural allies—BIPOC and white working poor, BIPOC feminists and white feminists, Jewish and BIPOC targets of white supremacy—conflict between the two main historical targets of Europe’s Christian nationalism—Jews and Muslims—seemed to fit the same pattern. In that conflict I recognized the stamp of the “divide and conquer” strategy used for centuries by European elites to enact their imperial ambitions, all culminating in their global colonial land-and-wealth-grab, including the inhuman othering and violence of enslavement, dispossession and genocide. I started looking for where those same elites divided these two natural allies.

I didn’t have to look far. In 1917, British Foreign Secretary Arthur Balfour sent a declaration to the newly formed Zionist community of England and Ireland promising to establish “…a national home for the Jews in Palestine,” in exchange for their military help fighting the Ottoman Empire’s centuries-old Muslim rule in the region. The declaration advanced a foreign policy inaugurated by Lord Palmerston in the 1840’s: to encourage the emigration of British Jews to Palestine to create an imperial footprint in the Middle East. It involved arbitrarily carving up the Ottoman Empire with France and Russia, claiming a “mandate” to occupy Palestine, and allowing the sale of land within it to non-resident Jewish individuals and groups.

At the time, Zionism was only twenty years old, the brain child of the Austrian Theodor Hertzl and a handful of secular Jews convinced that the only way to protect the Jewish people from Christian antisemitism was to take a page from Christian Europe’s imperialist playbook. The plan was to colonize part of the historic homeland of the Jewish people and displace the indigenous, overwhelmingly Muslim population living on that land. In light of the history of Europe and the Middle East, the plan proposed what amounted to a Jewish European crusade. Zionism at that point had been critically received by most of the Jewish community, especially religious Jews, as a secular political project contrary to their moral values and cultural legacy.

The tide began to turn when the Ottoman Empire collapsed in 1922, and the British proclaimed a colonial mandate in Palestine, promoting large scale Jewish immigration and the establishment of a Jewish state. Britain’s plan to enlist European Jews as proxy colonizers came to fruition when the British mandate ended after World War II, with the influx of Jewish refugees from the Holocaust, and the UN plan to partition Palestine into Israeli and Palestinian states. This led to the 1948 civil war between the Arab population and Zionist militias, culminating in the expulsion of 750,000 Palestinians from their homes into the Gaza strip, the catastrophe Palestinians call “the Nakba.” So while Zionists entered the picture as willing pawns in the European project of global colonization, by 1948 they fully stepped into the role Balfour cast them in: Britain’s proxy colonizers. As the heirs to the global colonizing engine of the British Empire, the Americans soon jumped on the British bandwagon. Since then, Israel has increasingly acted as a colonizing power, with constant British and U.S. support, especially as of the 1967 war, after which it forged the apartheid-like regime of occupation that contributed to the rise of Hamas and the current conflagration.      

When the British orchestrated the creation of a Jewish state in Palestine, they did so with no regard for the fact that encouraging Jewish immigrants to colonize the Middle East, displace Palestinians, and alienate their historic Muslim allies, meant putting them in an even more legally, morally and militarily precarious situation than they would have been in had they stayed in post-war Europe. This is why I’ve come to think of the British-American engineering of the Zionist project not as a restorative gesture towards the Jewish people, but as another covert expulsion, another insidious act of antisemitism meant to serve the aims of Anglo-American global dominance. It is truly disturbing that this act of calculated self-interest and cold disregard was framed as support for the Jewish people, as a step to insure Jews will “never again” suffer a fate like the Nazi Holocaust.

In effect, by advancing, endorsing and backing the Zionist plan, Britain, America, France, Russia and other U.N. member nations were essentially declaring their unwillingness to actually make their countries safe homes for the Jewish people. That unwillingness validated what remains the very real worst fear driving Zionism: that Jews will never be secure in any Christian-dominant nation; that they can only be “safe” by forcibly displacing Palestinians to create a Jewish state, reenacting one of the original sins of Europe’s colonizing nations, and planting the seeds for the now 75 year old existential conflict with their Arab neighbors.

I believe the escalating violence in Gaza since October 7th has two intertwined root causes: 1) the global colonizing drive of Israel’s Anglo-American architects, who preyed on the fears of Zionist Jews, enlisting them to create Israel as their proxy colonial outpost, in a way that violated the legal and moral rights of the indigenous Palestinians; and 2) the reenactment by Zionist Jews of their two thousand years of genocidal trauma at the hands of Christian Europe, by identifying with the Christian perpetrators of that trauma, adopting their colonizing violence and genocidal Islamophobia, and then mistaking their historic neighbors and natural allies for the aggressors in the conflict, as if the Palestinians, not the Christians had been the perpetrators of Europe’s two millennia old campaign of antisemitism.

 For Palestinians, being demonized for struggling to regain the land and homes violently seized from them over the past eight decades reenacts the intergenerational trauma of centuries of Christian Europe’s Islamophobic campaign to expel Muslims from Europe and colonize the Middle East. That campaign began with the Norman conquest of the Caliphate of Sicily and the first crusades in the 11th century, went on to include massive medieval Muslim expulsions from Spain and the Balkans, and culminated in modern Europe’s colonization of most of the Islamic world. In contrast, apart from three periods when Europe’s Christian crusaders conquered and occupied “the Holy Land,” Muslims, Jews and Christians in general had lived peacefully together for thirteen centuries of Muslim rule in Palestine.

All that stopped with the Nakba and the declaration of the Israeli state in 1948. From the Arab perspective, this colonization by Anglo-American-backed Zionists would naturally be experienced as the latest and most devastating European crusade, in which the Jewish founders of Israel effectively took on themselves the twelve-century legacy of Christian Europe’s genocidal Islamophobia. From the Israeli perspective, when Palestinians and/or their allies in other Muslim nations challenged the legal and moral right of Jews to violently displace their Arab neighbors, seize their land, set up a Jewish state, and control the region, they were experienced through the lens of Jewish trauma as continuing Christian Europe’s twenty-century legacy of genocidal antisemitism.

 Of course, the recent attack by Hamas on October 7th understandably re-traumatized Israeli Jews, given its horrific level of brutality and violence, impacting most as a reenactment of the Holocaust. Yet tragically, that experience of reenactment has blinded many Israelis and Jews around the world to the broader context for the rise of Hamas: the long-term traumatic impact on Palestinians of Israel’s violent colonization and occupation of Palestinian land. And it has also tragically blinded Israeli’s war cabinet and military intelligence to the fact that their short-sighted strategy of treating all Gazans as Hamas is undermining the only real hope of long-term security for Israelis and Palestinians: a just, negotiated settlement. Far from making anyone safe, Israel’s siege is fueling the cycle of trauma in both populations, consigning everyone in the region to more generations of collective trauma. While only 25% of Palestinians supported Hamas on the eve of October 7th, 2023, given the disproportionate and brutal nature of the Israeli retaliation, that percentage has since tripled, proving the tragically self-defeating long-term impact of the current war.

 So for both Israelis and Palestinians, this conflict transformed their historic relationship from one of being natural allies, with Christian Europe as a common enemy, to becoming each other’s worst enemies, transferring onto each other the intergenerational legacy of being traumatized for centuries by Christian Europe’s double-edged sword of antisemitism and Islamophobia. The history of this devastating conflict shows that its deepest roots lie with neither the Israelis nor the Palestinians, but with the imperial ambitions and colonizing schemes of Britain and the U.S. Two otherwise confounding facts support this.

First, within the U.S., the explosion of this crisis and conflict has lead to clear spikes in both Islamophobia and antisemitism at the same time. This reflects the dominant culture’s deep roots in the white supremacist “crusading” culture of Christian Europe, with its double-edged sword—othering, expelling and genociding both Muslims and Jews. Second, the failure of the U.S., as the most powerful nation on earth, to be able to act as an honest, effective peace-broker in the Middle East for over seventy-five years reflects the dominant culture’s blind spot for the original sins of its own colonizing history. These sins—colonizing Turtle Island, displacing and genociding its indigenous peoples, and creating an apartheid system to maintain the enslavement of African-Americans—keep the mostly white elites of both U.S. political parties from acknowledging the genocidal impact of Israel’s colonization of the region, and the racialized violence of the apartheid system imposed by its occupation of Palestinian lands.

 . . . . . . . .   

Assuming there is some truth to this analysis, what are the prospects for the kind of dialogue and reconciliation that could lead to long term peace in the region? While it may seem academic or historical, I believe this analysis points to the one long view that can help all involved see beyond the othering narratives that fan the flames of terror and hate, and trap both sides in mutually reinforcing and self-fulfilling violent reactivities. It allows true allies of Israel and the Jewish people to lay bare the root cause of the ongoing conflict—white Christian colonialism, with its toxic mix of racism, anti-semitism and Islamophobia—hopefully encouraging Jews to temper Zionism with their Judaism, and to repair and restore their historic alliance with their Palestinian neighbors and the Muslim world. At the same time, it helps true allies of Palestine and its people spotlight their 75 year-long catastrophe and offers people of non-Muslim backgrounds—Israelis, Jews and Christians around the world—to recognize, stop and reverse the traumatic impact of Israel’s proxy colonization and occupation of Palestine, which has reenacted the Christian West’s centuries of crusading genocide and Islamophobia. 

 My aim in sharing this analysis is not just to restate my call for a cease fire, but to do so in a way that challenges those of us witnessing the violence from the safety of the U.S., Europe and the Commonwealth to own how it implicates all of us who have benefited in any way from Christian Europe’s global campaign of colonization and genocide. My hope is that implicating ourselves in the conflict will humble and spur us to take responsibility for learning enough and reflecting enough to meet this moment, which is so ripe for collective awakening and change. Of course, in order to serve as bridges across such troubled waters we must not just see clearly to the root causes of the trauma on both sides of the conflict but also calm the waves of vicarious trauma that would only add to the harm and prevent us from being of any real help. Without such critical self-awareness and mindful self-care, I believe that trying to stop the traumatic cycle of threat-perception, othering narratives, aversive emotions and violent reactions that drives the cycle of genocidal violence in the Middle East and elsewhere is like trying to stop a train that has already left the station.

The Missing Link

Confronting the Anthropology of Patriarchy, Colonization and Genocide

Before sharing my strategy for working with how exposure to genocidal violence activates our trauma reactivity, I believe it’s essential to trace the roots of conflicts like the one in the Middle East not just to their historic roots but even deeper—to their roots in human prehistory and evolution. Even more tragic than the devastating crisis in Gaza unfolding as I write this is the fact that similar conflicts between rival nations, diverse ethnic groups, and clashing religious culture blocks are taking place around the world and have throughout recorded history, not as an exception but as part of a horrific rule. In order to put an end to the age-old cycle of collective trauma caused by patriarchy, colonialism, capitalism, ethnonationalism and enslavement, I believe we need to trace the roots of today’s global conflicts to their timeless root causes in human prehistory, as well as the primal roots of self-enclosure, fear and violence within our evolutionary sociobiology.

 While the current conflict in the Middle East is rooted in modern Europe’s campaign of world colonization, the toxic mix of patriarchy, militarism, colonialism, enslavement and ethnoreligious supremacy is not exclusive to the modern era or the Christian West. In fact, that mix seems to be at least as old as humanity’s first mercantile societies; and was common to varying degrees and in varied forms across the agrarian “river valley” civilizations that flourished in what is often called the “axial age,” from 1500 to 500 BCE, in Nigeria, Egypt, Greece, Anatolia, Mesopotamia, Persia, India, China and Central and South America.

 Some follow Lithuanian anthropologist Marija Gimbutas in tracing this toxic culture to the dawn of the Bronze Age (3300-1500 BCE), when Neolithic farming communities in Eurasia were overrun by Caucasian nomadic peoples called the Kurgan or Yamnaya. These early colonizers had a patriarchal warrior culture, worshiped male sky gods, spoke Proto-Indo-European, invented wheeled ox-carts and horse-drawn chariots, and made bronze daggers and bludgeons, allowing them to invade and occupy their peaceful, Neolithic neighbors, installing colonizing patriarchy across much of Eurasia. While the specifics of this story are still being worked out, there is growing consensus among anthropologists that the now dominant cultural style of militaristic patriarchy co-evolved with complex economies, and diverse, populous states, and that prior societies were generally less violent, more cooperative and varied widely in their reliance on matriarchal, patriarchal and mixed social systems.

Given the malleability of human nature and the complexity of our shared human genome—featuring equal parts matriarchal Bonobo, patriarchal Chimpanzee, and a handful of exclusively human genes—I believe that patriarchy and its culture of exclusivism, hierarchy and violence emerged out of a complex interplay between deep-rooted survival instincts and evolving contextual challenges. As human groups grew in numbers and expanded their surplus resources, smaller tribes of extended kin who shared intertwined familial bonds gave way to larger populations of mixed lineage and descent who shared collective economic and political interests but not close emotional affinities.

This transition lead to cultural traditions and political structures that depended on creating bonds of loyalty to impersonal institutions and figures, rather than intimate personal relationships to family, friends and neighbors. Insofar as the flourishing of privileged individuals, families and communities in these rapidly expanding social systems depended on the corporate security and productivity of the whole society, religious and civic education was commonly structured to train citizens regardless of gender to suppress their natural faculties of embodied loving connection and invest instead in identifying with socially constructed roles and relationships that promised them and their loved ones a place within the larger system. Examples include the pharaoh system in ancient Egypt and the caste system in ancient India.

 In order to counteract the strong force of embodied loving connections to kin, many patriarchal cultures and institutions resorted to intimidating their citizens with violent ritual displays that evoked terror, shame, shock and awe. Rituals like the Roman circus and Mayan rites of human sacrifice allowed patriarchies to culturally reproduce a collective traumatic dissociation among citizens of all genders from our primal connective nature and Bonobo heritage, effectively locking us all into straightjackets of separation, disconnection and domination that drew on our trauma instincts and our Chimp genetic heritage. As these straightjackets of traumatic self-enclosure disconnected us from ourselves, others and nature, they simultaneously bound us to socially constructed identities, our assigned social locations and roles, which supposedly promised some semblance of belonging and a token membership to a shadow world of disjoined relationships with others and the earth.

Integral to this violently constructed social order and traumatic dissociation from our shared humanity is a binary us-vs-them logic of in-group cohesion and out-group exclusion that thrives on othering, dehumanizing, and harming individuals and communities identified as exploitable and/or threatening. This supremacist conditioning allows patriarchal groups and societies to rationalize and mobilize organized violence against other groups and societies, from gender oppression, racial oppression, religious persecution and class exploitation to colonization, warfare and genocide. We see it tragically at work in the centuries long legacy of Christian Europe’s colonialism, Islamophobia and antisemitism unfolding today in the Middle East.

Breaking the Cycle of Genocidal Violence

Four Strategies for Individual and Collective Human Awakening

Given this depth analysis, how do we learn to work through our natural tendency and social conditioning to react to the violence in the Middle East and elsewhere with othering narratives, reactive emotions like terror and hate, and our own vicarious trauma reactions? Whether we identify more with one side or the other, or with both, those of us still connected to our shared humanity naturally feel heartbroken and torn apart witnessing the devastating loss and harm, in ways that activate other trauma we’ve witnessed or endured. On the other hand, those of us partly or wholly split off from our vulnerable, feeling selves by prior trauma or by the global dissociation of patriarchal social conditioning may feel for one group or the other we identify as victim or protector, or may simply feel overwhelmed, shocked and numbed by the brutality of the conflict, unable to empathize with either group.

All of these are eminently human reactions; all of them common symptoms of re-traumatization and/or vicarious trauma. All can occur at the level of the individual or equally at the collective level of whole communities and populations. All of these reflect the natural activation of self-protective instincts and self-enclosing trauma habits in the face of events we experience as immanently threatening. In this case, the threat trigger is exposure to the breakdown of common human empathy, kindness and compassion, caused by othering/blaming narratives, the stirring/weaponization of terror and hate, visceral trauma reflexes of dissociation and armoring, and rageful/vengeful violent reactions targeting those dehumanized and demonized as evil.

The strategies I’ve developed for working through my own traumatic reactivity to this and other genocidal conflicts are based on my lifelong practice of the healing wisdom and arts of Buddhist psychology and contemporary psychotherapy. And they vary widely as they range across all four levels of traumatic reactivity: narrative, affective, visceral and behavioral. In the remainder of this piece I’ll touch on the strategies I have used for disarming trauma reactions at each of these four levels.

 The first strategy I use is for catching and correcting othering narratives that lead me to identify with/humanize one person/group as “I, me, mine” and distance/dehumanize a different person/group as “they, them, their.” Given the binary logic of the symbolic mind, I carefully scan the narratives running in my head for a one-sided diet of words, images, and examples. When my narrative names only positive qualities in the person/group on one side of a traumatic event and names only negative features in the person/group on the other side, I try to challenge my biased thinking by seeking out the opposite qualities/features in both parties.                                  

This is not to say that there are no innocent victims who need to be acknowledged and protected or no malicious perpetrators who need to be named and restrained. What it does mean is that once we assess and name who is doing what to whom, in the next breath we must look deeper to name the root causes and conditions on both sides that help us connect with the human complexity of all involved. This might mean pointing to the underlying individual and collective legacies of trauma that help clarify how “hurt people hurt people,” to humanize perpetrators; and also pointing out legacies of prior trauma to help deepen our empathy and understanding of the complex impact of current traumatic events on the more vulnerable. This is not to suggest any false equivalence between the harm being done here and now and the prior harm that contextualizes it, or to rationalize or excuse the violent thoughts, motives and actions of those who do harm. It is simply to try to hold the present harm within a broader, deeper awareness that also makes space for the humanity and complex histories of all involved. 

Another type of othering narrative is the kind that tells me to ignore or bypass the traumas taking place around me, by distancing myself from the events or those involved with binary thinking that others both parties. “Both sides are deluded/wrong,” “Their conflict doesn’t involve/affect me,” “What’s going on between them just doesn’t matter.” This type of othering is more insidious since it’s based on the unconscious separation we humans make between ourselves and everyone/everything else, centering our own concerns/perspective and othering all that is not “I, me, mine.” Besides its deep roots in our unconscious instincts of self-enclosure, another factor that makes such bypassing narratives so dense and common is the pervasive and insidious social conditioning towards hyper-individualism built into modern colonizing capitalist culture, to divide and control the various groups it oppresses and exploits.  

Once I’ve begun to expose the implicit bias in my thinking and introduce non-dual wisdom and universal compassion into how I narrate traumatic events in my head and in dialogue, the next strategy I turn to involves scanning my emotional response to the suffering taking place, to name and own any traumatic emotions stirred up from my prior trauma or my primal survival instincts. While primal emotions like outrage, terror, panic and shame are perfectly normal responses to witnessing life-threatening violence, they often reflect the blinding force of unresolved personal trauma or instinctive survival drives not yet humanized by social-emotional learning. In either case, when we are flooded by such primal affects, we are likely to have our higher social emotional intelligence hijacked in ways that block our capacities for equanimity, perspective-taking, complex insight and unbiased empathy, not to mention skill in reconciliation and peacemaking.

This is why my second strategy is to scan and name the strong emotions I feel when witnessing present trauma, looking for affective patterns that are colored by my prior trauma or by primal survival drives that stem from feeling threatened or unsafe myself. When I identify either pattern or both, I turn my attention to exploring and working with those emotions using mindful self-awareness, self-acceptance, self-inquiry and self-care, based on practices like mindful self-compassion or the RAIN of self-compassion. Once I’ve understood how my traumatic emotions or survival drives have been activated, and begin to work through them with healing insight and care, I check to see if my heart feels safe enough to stay open to the present trauma I’m witnessing so that I can hold it with some degree of unbiased empathy and wise compassion for all involved, myself included.

As with narratives of denial that bypass trauma experienced by people we other, there is another type of emotional reaction that presents paradoxically as having no strong feeling at all in the face of exposure to life-threatening violence. Feeling flat or numb when we’re exposed to violent trauma is in fact one of the most common emotional reactions to trauma, whether we experience the trauma directly ourselves or indirectly in others. It reflects the dissociative reaction characteristic of direct or vicarious trauma, in which our conscious mind simply disconnects or splits off from experience that might otherwise be emotionally overwhelming or crippling.

In my experience it’s crucial to be on the lookout for his type of flat affect or bland denial in the face of trauma—feeling like “It just doesn’t matter,” or “Why should I care”—since it is also typical of the global disconnect from our affective or embodied experience that stems from the way patriarchal, racist and capitalist dominant cultures work to split our minds off from our full human presence, to make us easier to control and exploit. The strategy I use in this case is to turn towards the trauma taking place and engage it with my full presence of mind and open-heartedness, until I begin to connect with my real human feeling about the harm I’m witnessing to precious members of my human family. I do this until it helps me access genuine feelings of broken-heartedness, feelings that stir a felt sense of common humanity and typically touch on my own traumatic emotional memories and primal emotional reactions like deep compassion, the urge to help, and feelings of outrage.

The third main strategy I use for disarming my trauma response to witnessing lethal violence relates to the visceral reactivity often stirred by vicarious trauma. Feeling our body gripped by the primal survival reflexes of fight-or-flight sympathetic arousal and/or faint-or-freeze parasympathetic paralysis is as common and human as stress and trauma themselves. So whether I find myself flooded with my own traumatic emotional memories or oddly flat and numb in the face of trauma, I practice feeling into the visceral sensations going on in my body under the surface waves of heightened emotion or the oddly placid veneer of calm. By bringing interoceptive awareness to my whole body as I witness trauma, I can scan for telltale signs of sympathetic fight-or-flight activation—like knots or butterflies in the stomach, an elevated heart rate, or sweaty palms—and/or signs of strong parasympathetic faint-freeze activity—like a gag in the throat, feelings of nausea or collapse, global numbing, or rigid guarding in the abdomen or pelvis. When I encounter the former, I practice slowing, deepening or even holding my breath and prolonging my exhale; when I encounter the latter I practice rotating my neck or belly, massaging my face, shoulders and limbs, and prolonging my inhale.

As this bottom-up strategy takes effect, re-balancing my autonomic nervous system with mindful breathing, massage or movement, I usually begin to feel more fully connected to my body, more vulnerable and alive. Hopefully, I start feeling safer in my body and more able to sense and hold the waves of emotion moving through me, including the heartbreak I feel witnessing the senseless re-enactment of trauma, as in Gaza, the Ukraine, Sudan and elsewhere. Rebalancing my nervous system in this way not only helps calm my visceral reactivity in the face of trauma but also helps soften and melt the embodied lockdown of my freeze reflex, which underlies the sense of helplessness, hopelessness and paralysis that typically accompanies trauma and blocks our human responsiveness. In this way, this third major strategy also helps to undo the affective flatness and numbness of dissociation from embodied emotion—which stems from the activation of the primal, parasympathetic freeze reflex—restoring and reconnecting us to the emotional fullness of our common humanity.

Finally, the last strategy involves leveraging the other three to avert reactive habits of behavior that arise reflexively when our minds, hearts and bodies are locked in survival mode by trauma. It also helps to unlock our natural capacity to respond to potential and actual threats with prosocial intent and socially engaged actions that embody our full humanity. This strategy relies on two related practices: the art of responsive attunement known as “giving and taking” (Tib. Tong-len); and the art of emulating mentors known as “mentor-archetype bonding” (Skt. Guru-devata-yoga).

Once we’ve effectively woken up from the trance of trauma at the levels of connective narrative, emotional open-heartedness and visceral responsiveness, we have the presence of mind, heart and body to notice the emergence of traumatic behavioral reactions and shift towards wiser, more skilled responses. The art of giving and taking offers one strategy for cultivating wiser, more skillful responses to trauma, based on attuning our minds, hearts and bodies empathically to those experiencing acute trauma and/or a reenactment of prior trauma. By taking our cues from mindful attention and heartfelt openness towards those in the line of fire and by giving whatever feels responsive to their moment-to-moment experience, we effectively open our system to an embodied intersubjective bond that can then evoke more connective, attuned responses. Sustaining this open, mutual attunement over time also allows skillful adjustments to ongoing feedback to our efforts to offer support, aid or help. Of course, such sustained attunement also requires that we stay present to our vicarious reactivity to the other’s suffering, so that we can note and calm it in real time, to stay genuinely present and open over time. This ongoing presence and open connection can be further stabilized by enhancing the art of taking care and giving love through “mounting” our energetic exchange with others on the in- and out-breath, a technique that helps balance and regulate our autonomic nervous system and so maintain ongoing visceral presence and responsiveness in the face of trauma.

The second strategy I use for avoiding reactive behavior and accessing wise, skillful responsiveness builds on the contemplative art of role-modeling known as mentor-archetype bonding. In this practice, we guide and facilitate our wise, skilled responsiveness using our primal social learning capacity for emulating role-models whose way of being and acting inspire us. By envisioning our mentors or archetypal ideals in our mind’s eye or even envisioning ourselves as our mentor-archetype, we align our minds, hearts and bodies with their embodied presence and skill, effectively setting their way of being and acting as a template or guide for our embodied action. In essence, we are asking our minds, hearts and bodies, “What would Buddha do in this situation?” or “What would MLK do?” This strategy not only serves as a selective filter, pointing away from reactive behaviors and towards wiser, more skillful responses, but it also helps calm our own traumatic reactivity by offering our mind/body system reassuring cues that we are not alone but protected and guided by wiser, more capable mentors.

Of course, we may be painfully aware that adding our own traumatic reactivity to the trauma experienced by others is harmful to us and likely not helpful to those we’re concerned with, but at the same time feel daunted by the healing work it would take to transform our reactivity into skillful responsiveness. The sobering fact is, we are all wired for survival, and our traumatic stress reactivity naturally takes hold of us in the face of threats to our safety or the safety of others. So the rub is, in order to prepare ourselves to respond rather than react in the heat of the moment, most of us will need to prime ourselves through a sustained process of mind/body healing, contemplative learning and training in crucial skills. Yet despite the cost of such preparation in time, effort and application, in my view, any individual or group who aspires to sustain engagement with the pervasive trauma that plagues us individually and collectively today would benefit enormously from that investment, both in personal integration, resilience and well-being, and in social emotional capacity and effectiveness.

The bottom line is, given our mixed evolutionary legacy and our multi-life burden of individual and collective trauma, in order for our species to successfully navigate our current transition from a war-torn patchwork of competing local cultures all too often driven by trauma to a cohesive global community based on compassion, we will all need to invest in this kind of transformative inner work. And in order for that to take place, a critical mass of people in a majority of cultures around the planet will need to shift their consensus away from the dominant systems of militarism, racism and patriarchy towards a healing counterculture of feminism, pacifism and deep equity. Only such a global movement can enable humanity as a whole to commit to the kind of universal education in disarming trauma and cultivating compassion that will empower us to flourish together as one human family with all life on earth.

Naturally, in the heat of genocidal violence of the kind we are witnessing as I write this in Gaza, Ukraine, the Congo and Sudan, such a hopeful, long-term vision seems just to bypass the immediacy of the suffering on the ground and the life-or-death urgency of the here and now. We tell ourselves that something much more concrete needs to happen, and that no individuals or groups can break free of their trauma legacy as long as such violence continues. And yet, trying to stop the mass reenactment of trauma without at the same time targeting its root causes leaves us constantly reacting to the next explosion of genocidal violence. So while I wholeheartedly agree that the deep inner work of uprooting our own trauma system and the vision of spreading a counterculture of non-violence globally cannot substitute for doing all we can to stop the harm being done right now, it seems plain to me that the opposite is also true.

We live in an age when mobile phones, social media and global translation apps have torn down the veils of language, culture and geography which have separated us from each other for millennia; an age where we witness trauma and genocide face to face in real time, sometimes every day. Yet it is also an age when we understand the destructive role of stress and trauma more fully than ever before, along with the power of timeless practices of contemplative self-healing to transform trauma and fully develop our human potential. So more than ever before in human history, now is the time for a global awakening to our shared humanity, made real by an individual and collective resistance to the cult of patriarchal violence that has separated us from our deeper potential, from one another, and from the earth for too long.

It has never been so easy to see the common humanity beneath our surface differences, as we look into one another’s eyes and hear each other’s voices via social media. And we now finally understand how to disrupt and transform the culture of institutionalized trauma that has separated us from one another, from our shared humanity, and from our living planet for hundreds of generations. Now is the time for the culture of othering and violence dividing our world and the legacy of fragmentation and violence dividing our psyches and societies to give way to a new era of global healing and universal compassion.

While it is no substitute for direct action—political resistance, financial giving, raising consciousness, or mobilizing aid—doing inner work on our critical thinking, empathic attunement, embodied presence and engagement can help till the soil and plant seeds for a better future of human solidarity and global belonging. In fact, doing the inner work of reeducating ourselves, deepening attunement, presence and engagement is not just crucial to resisting our own trauma legacy and becoming ready, willing and able to show up for others; it also empowers us to take action in more skilled and collaborative ways, opening us to the wisdom of those in the line of fire, and allowing us to learn from them whether and how we can help co-facilitate change.

So whether you’re seeking to break the cycle of othering and violence in your own psyche, or to break the collective cycles of othering and violence traumatizing the world we share, I believe any path to meaningful change requires doing our inner work. As Atisha said in Seven Points that Transform the Mind, “Don’t depend on external conditions. Take up the principal (practice) right now.” I close by offering this humble prayer for all beings everywhere:

 May all beings be safe from harm and protected from violence
 May they have shelter, water, food, medicine and education
 May they live in dignity, without fear of their human rights being violated
 May they be entirely free from suffering and its causes
 May they have lasting happiness and its causes
 May they know the blessings of gratitude and shared joy
 May they live in unwavering inner and outer peace
 May they live understanding their interdependence with all beings

May 1, 2024
The Cliff Haven
Mannahatta Island
Lenapehoking Land

by Joe Loizzo

As the devastating tide of violence and loss, terror and rage in the Middle East keeps rising day by day, our hearts break for all the lives already lost, for all those in harm’s way, and for all those whose lives have been irrevocably scarred by the collective trauma unfolding there. The fact that this tragedy is taking place at the heart of what half of humanity calls the Holy Land, between communities who share a common spiritual legacy as well as a common ancestry, is a  painful reminder of how far we still have to go as a global community to own our shared humanity deeply enough to fully reconcile our differences and flourish together as the family we are.

Adding to our heartbreak is the cutting awareness that the trauma unfolding before our eyes is fueling the very intergenerational cycle of traumatic reenactment that caused it, and so burdens future generations and puts them at greater risk. More salt in the wound is the harsh reality that this conflict is entangled with countless other conflicts around the world—from the wars in Ukraine, Azerbaijan, Yemen and Ethiopia to the internal conflicts in Syria, Afghanistan, Iran, Tibet, Xinjiang, Hong Kong, and the United States—all of which compound our collective suffering and add to the work of healing that lies ahead.

What can we do to avoid adding in any way to the legacy of collective trauma each of us has inherited in different ways, and to advance the inner and outer work of healing and reconciliation we and our world so desperately need today? Fortunately, alongside our shared legacy of trauma, we also share the legacy of humanity’s sage leaders of non-violence, deep healing and reconciliation. As a community that seeks refuge in Shakyamuni Buddha and his tradition, I believe we are called by our predicament today to contemplate his teaching that only love and compassion can break the cycle of violence and hatred. If he were here now, no doubt he would guide us to do everything we can to bring love and care to stop harm, alleviate pain and end suffering, wherever it lives, whatever shape it takes. And I expect he would also remind us to bring that same love and care to our own traumatic fear, rage, and bias, so that we can help break the cycle of reactivity and ongoing harm that would cause us and all those we touch, future pain and suffering.

In the midst of our heartbreak, now is the time to let our hearts break open, to renew our commitment, to look beneath our biases and reactive emotions, to own and deepen our shared humanity, so that we can be one small beat in the global movement it will take to bring healing, reconciliation, love and compassion to our our whole human family, and to all life on earth, once and for all.

Within the Nalanda Tradition, we practice embodying the spirit of resolve to transform ourselves and our world through prayer and invocation of mentors. The prayer for peace below ends with invoking the Archetypal Buddha of wise compassion, Avalokiteshvara, and reciting his world-making vow, Om Mani Padme Hum Hree, May My Mind Be the Jewel and the Flower of Compassion, and by invoking the Archetypal Buddha of Compassionate Wisdom, Manjushri, and reciting his world-making vow, Om Ara Pachana Dhee, May I and All Beings Quickly Awaken.

May all wars and conflicts quickly cease.

May all those wounded, held hostage, caught in the crossfire or traumatized by violence and loss be well cared for, released, kept safe, healed and reunited with loved ones.

May all the legacies of harm, bias and trauma dividing our human family be reconciled and healed soon.

May all beings know the joy that transcends grief and loss.

May all beings learn to live in equanimity, undisturbed by bias, fear, anger, and sorrow.

OM MANI PADME HUM HREE

OM ARA PACHANA DHEE

by Geri Loizzo

The Mindfulness Revolution has helped many taste a life of more clarity and ease, but the promise and depth of traditional Mindfulness goes much deeper. Our Contemplative Psychotherapy Program (CPP) Mindfulness Year will not only update you on the latest research and practical applications of mindfulness, self-compassion, and loving-kindness, but will also ground you in the profound wisdom and vast healing power of the timeless contemplative science and practice of Buddhist psychology, meditation, and ethics.  

Current views on spiritual bypassing—using our practice to avoid difficult emotions or situations—are a good case in point. In this CPP class video, Joe Loizzo MD, PhD, Nalanda Institute Founder and Academic Director, explains the rigorous way Buddhist Psychology counteracts bypassing from the get-go while also challenging the opposite problem of spiritual nihilism that afflicts psychology today, a problem he calls psychological cave-dwelling. 


Editor’s Note: Find out more about this year’s Contemplative Psychotherapy Programs. Offerings begin this fall.


by Dr. Joe Loizzo

I recently had the pleasure of connecting (in person!) with contemplative neuroscientist David Vago and some of our mutual friends at the inaugural meeting of the International Society of Contemplative Research (ISCR) he founded with Nalanda Institute board member Doris Chang and others. Set on the lovely campus of the UC San Diego, the meeting brought together Buddhist scholars, neuroscientists, social justice researcher-activists and clinical researchers to explore the future of interdisciplinary dialogue and inquiry in the fast-growing field of contemplative science and practice.

(more…)

by Geri Loizzo


Editor’s note: Read on and then enjoy all of the videos from this special in-person event.


The laws of impermanence teach us that things are changing all the time — a teaching that has been especially apparent in the time of covid. Like all institutions of learning, Nalanda Institute has had to adapt to the change from in-person contact to online classes. For many of us, keeping a feeling of connection and intimacy in the little square boxes of Zoom has posed a challenge, even as the benefits of becoming more accessible to new friends connecting around the globe have been felt and greatly appreciated. While not IRL (in real life), you could say this new accessibility has provided more opportunities to experience a wider variety of the courses and daily meditation offerings IRT (in real time). Still, for some, the yearning for an in-person experience has been brewing for quite some time!

(more…)

by Dan Donohue

On November 15th 2022, Dr. Joe Loizzo and Elazar Aslan, co-authors and co-developers of the Boundless Leadership award-winning book and program, offered a 90-minute webinar in which they shared three counter-intuitive steps (and the science behind these steps) to improving our relationships. The webinar also included a guided compassion meditation — a key ingredient to improving our social interactions. Joe and Elazar also took questions from the audience and discussed real world answers to questions such as ‘How do I feel compassion for coworkers that are mean and aggressive?’ and ‘How do I recover from feelings of shame after being put down by a coworker or boss?’

This short class introduced just a few aspects of becoming a Boundless Leader. The Boundless Leadership program was developed to help people optimize their whole being — mind, heart and body — to make better decisions, engage more deeply with others and overcome internal fears that limit their ability to realize their full potential, whether at work, or in their personal lives.


The Boundless Leadership program begins anew January 2023.
Learn more and register
Save 20% with our Earlybird discount if you register by November 30th!


by Nalanda Institute

On June 22, 2022, Nalanda Institute for Contemplative Science along with the Wharton Center for Leadership and the Wharton Center for Human Resources hosted a panel discussion called The Great Return to Work: Ensuring Individual and Organizational Wellbeing in the New Normal.

(more…)

by Nalanda Institute

Sharon Salzberg video

On February 18, 2022 Nalanda Institute was honored to host an online Community Gathering with one of our favorite faculty, Sharon Salzberg, in dialogue with Nalanda Institute’s founder and academic director, Dr. Joe Loizzo.

It was a remarkable evening filled with mindfulness and loving-kindness meditations guided by Sharon Salzberg. Sharon also shared recollections and lessons from her life-long practice and teachings of loving-kindness.

(Video and audio documentation in English, Spanish and Portuguese may be found below)

(more…)

gratitude

In his Stages of the Altruist’s Path, the 5th century Nalanda master, Asanga, taught that gratitude emerges from acknowledging the kindness and the care we’ve been shown by all of life—the kindness of our parents in giving us life, of our human ancestors in tending and caring for the earth and creating our culture and way of life; and the kindness of nature that’s generative and sustains life. This practice requires accepting all of the difficulties and the harm we see and have experienced in a knowing but not passive way; yet sincerely remembering and connecting with all of the good. This is especially relevant as some prepare to celebrate Thanksgiving in the United States. Although it’s a holiday many recognize as an opportunity to express gratitude, it is also a national day of mourning for Native Americans. We must name and honor the entirety of this history. It is what’s necessary for gratitude to emerge.

(more…)

by Joe Loizzo, MD, PhD

It’s no secret that our work lives are becoming ever-more complex, fast-paced and stressful in our global, digital age. We need only look at how the COVID-19 pandemic has transformed the workplace to see how rapidly and radically the conditions of living and working in today’s fluid environment can change. At the same time, the pandemic has also laid bare pressing social and environmental needs—for true racial, gender and financial equity, and for a more sustainable economy—that demand fundamental changes in the way we think, live and lead.

(more…)

by Joe Loizzo


Editor’s note: The following are excerpts from Tarka, Volume 0, “Yoga Philosophy, On the Scholar-Practitioner,” a publication from Embodied Philosophy. The full article is available here as well, courtesy of Embodied Philosophy.


Have you ever wondered why the trend in modern science, scholarship, and practical expertise seems inexorably headed in one direction— towards more and more narrow specialization? I have. Since I was a teen, for some odd reason, this trend has felt so wrong to me that, in hindsight, much of my adult life and work have been dedicated to answering that question and reversing the trend. Here’s some of what I’ve learned and done on my journey thus far to bring the pieces of our humanity back together again. […]

(more…)

By Elazar Aslan

“That was a terrible meeting,” my client said in exasperation. “Honestly, I think they had their mind made up and nothing I did really mattered. Apparently they’ve had conversations about my project that did not even include me. There’s no way I can win…I really can’t take it anymore. I need to find a way out of here.”

As an executive coach, this is not an uncommon starting point for a conversation. Every day I try to guide my clients to use the challenges of the workplace to strengthen their capacity to go inwards and find a skillful response. Using clarity and self-awareness, we all can grow to avoid the negative consequences of a reactive mind. My clients learn early in our relationship that true leadership is borne from the radical leadership of self.

(more…)

Emma Seppala and Joe Loizzo

Editor’s Note: Nalanda Institute’s Director, Dr. Joe Loizzo recently sat down with Dr. Emma Seppälä for a conversation about compassion science and their hopes for the future. Dr. Seppälä is the Science Director at The Center for Compassion and Altruism Research at Stanford University. We present a small portion of their conversation here.

Dr. Seppälä is also our Guest of Honor at our 10th Annual Benefit on June 12th. Her talk entitled “Compassion Science: Healing Our Interconnected World”  further explores the topics presented here. Find out more about our forthcoming benefit.


Joe Loizzo: Welcome, Emma, and thanks so much for taking the time to speak with me about your work in the science of compassion. First of all, maybe you could fill us in about how you found your way to your unusual career.

Emma Seppälä: While I was doing my master’s degree at Columbia in East Asian languages in the late 90’s, I took a class with Bob Thurman, and decided to focus on Buddhist Studies. That lead me to the seminar you gave on Science, Spirituality and Healing in the Tibetan tradition, where I remember you urged me to go to a talk at Union Seminary by Richie Davidson and Dan Goleman on meditation research, remember?

(more…)

By Joe Loizzo

Emma Seppala

Editor’s Note: In this post Nalanda Institute’s Founder and Director, Dr. Joe Loizzo reviews two books written and edited by Dr. Emma Seppälä, this year’s Guest of Honor at our 10th Annual Benefit (June 12, 2019). As you’ll see, her writing, research, and position as Science Director of the Stanford Center for Compassion and Altruism Research aligns perfectly with Nalanda Institute’s mission. Read on to find out more about compassion in action.


Review: The Happiness Track: How to Apply the Science of Happiness to Accelerate Your Success (HarperOne, 2016), by Emma Seppälä, Ph.D.

For most of the modern age, our scientific view of human nature and our understanding of the social emotion of compassion have been drifting further and further apart. This is no accident. It reflects the widening gulf between modern science and religious ethics that has caused such a troubling divide in human culture and consciousness in our age. Specifically it reflects an intentional distortion of Darwin’s view of human “fitness” to mean that the traditional ethical values of love and compassion conflict with our natural strengths, and that such emotions are in fact sentimental weaknesses. Quietly over the last five decades, biology has begun to heal the modern divide and expose this distortion, helping us rediscover the wisdom in Darwin’s observation that “communities with the greatest number of sympathetic members would flourish best.”

(more…)

by Fiona Brandon

During our recent Mindfulness Year fall retreat, Joe Loizzo emphasized to the cohort that the development of the self is “a creative project,” but one that is not always in our favor. “There is a tendency once we make an interpretation [about ourselves or an experience]…to forget it was an interpretation. [We] just stamp it with the seal of reality because for one moment [the interpretation] was serviceable.” It can be shocking to look under the hood of this habitual pattern and see that we create lifelong fundamental beliefs about ourselves, and the world around us, based on interpretations that may have been true in one moment, but are inaccurate for subsequent moments in our lives!

The year begins with an understanding of the webs we weave. Pictured on retreat are San Francisco students with Dr. Joe Loizzo (second in top row) and Fiona Brandon (second in bottom row).

(more…)

by Fiona Brandon

When Sharon Salzberg lead San Francisco’s 2017 Spring Mindfulness Year retreat, she playfully challenged the notion that Mindfulness, “Seems to imply a complacency: be in the present moment without reacting. Sounds dull!” The students laughed. I appreciated how Sharon addressed the popular misunderstanding that the goal of mindfulness meditation is to have no thoughts and sit in some kind of fixed non-reactive state. When in reality, the four foundations of mindfulness — the main meditation practices taught during the Mindfulness Year of the Contemplative Psychotherapy Program — are anything but static.

San Francisco faculty Nalanda Institute

Sharon Salzberg with Mindfulness Year faculty Joe Loizzo, Linda Graham and Fiona Brandon.

(more…)